Spotlight customer reviews:
|
Customer Rating:  
Summary: A curate's egg...
Comment: ...good, in parts.
If I were giving stars for the performance, I would give an entire galaxy. Ms. Balsom's mastery of not only the usual trumpet and flugelhorn, but also the wicked little piccolo trumpet and the valveless natual instrument, are extraordinary - wonderful sound and flawless technique.
The problem is the music. The first pieces (Sweelinck, Bach, Purcell and a nice flugelhorn rendition of "Shenandoah") are great. But, alas, the final pieces are modern, meaning (to my ears anyway), strange, discordant things very useful for scaring the neighbours' cats out of our garden, but not much else. This, I realise, is a very personal opinion, and if you like modern music, this is worthy of five stars. I don't, and sadly can't.
Customer Rating:
Summary: Alison Balsom, Music for Trumpet & Organ
Comment: Balsom, Alison. Music for Trumpet & Organ
This is the first CD from Alison Balsom who was earlier this year awarded winner of the Young British Classical Performer of 2006. Recorded in 2002 it consists of a collection of eight pieces of music spanning some five centuries - from the Baroque era of Bach, Purcell & Sweelinck to the relatively contemporary music of Petr Eben. Quentin Thomas provides the organ accompaniment to Alison's various instruments used throughout this recording including natural trumpet, piccolo trumpet and flugelhorn.
This may seem a wide range of music to put on one disc, but to me the organ / trumpet instrument pairing has always suggested a somewhat timeless feel which has enabled the compositions of the Baroque period to sit comfortably with the modern day works for these instruments. Both the organ and trumpet have a purity of sound, a suggestion of importance and occasion which pairs the instruments so well.
The music chosen by Alison for this debut disc cannot be faulted. The opening track from Sweelinck's Variations is beautifully performed and is a great example of how composers of the Renaissance / Baroque period could take a relatively simple theme and work it into a masterpiece. For me this is a first rate piece of music which has become one of my favourites on this disc.
The disc continues with Bach's Allemande (originally scored for solo violin), Purcell's King Arthur, and a lovely traditional piece called Shenandoah for solo trumpet.
The music starts to get contemporary with Henri Tomasi's Semaine Saint a Cuzco (Holy Week in Cuzco), continuing with Massiaen's Vocalise-Etude.
The disc concludes with Petr Eben's Windows, and it is this piece that offers the greatest challenge to the listener. The work, written in 1980, was inspired by the Russian-French painter Marc Chagall's stained glass windows in the Hadassah Medical Centre in Jerusalem. The piece is extremely varied, sometimes mysterious and haunting but always demanding. It is not immediately easy to understand or appreciate but this makes it so much more rewarding on subsequent listening. I like it, and have come to compare it with Mussorgsky's familiar Pictures at an Exhibition.
In summary an excellent debut album by Alison Balsom, complemented superbly by the organ playing of Quentin Thomas.
Customer Rating:
Summary: Not as described. Do not buy.
Comment: Since 2002 EMI seem to have repressed this CD, and got it hugely wrong. My copy purchased in 2004 is correctly labelled on the box and the actual CD label.However the catalogue number on the CD rim is not as it should be 5756832 but reads EMI UDEN 5665832. I can't find that number but 5665822 seems to be what is really on the CD- half of a 2 CD set of the Coronation of QE2. NO Alison Balsom at all. So- avoid this pressing. It is not what is on the label.
Customer Rating:
Summary: Exemplary
Comment: Alison's an incredible trumpet player with an incredibly beautiful sound. Trumpet players everywhere should buy this for some absolutely stunning playing, interesting pieces and inspiration. A real celebration of the capabilities of the trumpet. The crossover of repetoire into music originally written for violin just works so well with Alison's playing. That sound gives me goosebumps. I really like the variety on this CD. All this from a radiohead fan.
|
|
